By Robert
Montgomery,
BASS Times Senior
Writer
(Reprinted with permission
of BASS Times)
CAIRO, Ga.-Ignoring concerns about
fisheries, ethics and legality, the Georgia
General Assembly has spurned the advice
of resource professionals and passed a
law to allow underwater or "deadhead"
logging in portions of the Flint and
Altamaha rivers of southern Georgia.
The law "is barely enforceable and
certainly not affordable," said Glen
Dowling, Executive Vice President of the
Georgia Wildlife Federation (GWF).
"It has already cost our DNR
[Department of Natural resources] thousands
of dollars, and the price tag will
only increase at the expense of Georgia's
anglers and recreational boaters."
That expense will come in the form
of degraded aquatic systems, possible
loss of access, and further stretching of
DNR's limited manpower and financial
resources. The General Assembly
charged the agency not only with developing
regulations for pulling the logs
from the bottom of the rivers, but also
with enforcement.
At the same time, said Dowling, the
DNR has been told to cut its budget, and
aquatic weed control might be considered
expendable.
"So, they would be taking away
access for thousands of anglers to give
[access] to a few loggers," the GWF vice
president added. "We have more than a
million anglers in Georgia, and we don't
want that negatively impacted."
Nor do the more than 120 conservation,
sportsman and environmental
organizations that make up the Georgia
Water Coalition want the rivers negatively
impacted.
"The importance of deadhead logs to
river health cannot be overestimated, as
these logs provide valuable fish habitat,
allow for high levels of invertebrate productivity,
and provide refuge for endangered
and threatened mussels," said the
coalition in a letter to the DNR, offering
recommendations for regulations.
"In southeastern coastal plain
streams, woody substrate habitats had a
higher diversity of species, higher biomass
and higher productivity than any
other habitat. Several species of game
fish feed almost exclusively on these
invertebrates."
The Submerged Timber Task Force
also expressed concerns about the health
of fish and aquatic species when, in
March 2003, it recommended that recovery
of submerged timber not be allowed
in Georgia, based on biological, legal,
economic and historical concerns.
Ignoring the advice, the General
Assembly passed a law during the final
hours of its recent session allowing
removal of logs from the river bottom.
Those who receive licenses will be
allowed to pull up the thousands of logs
that sank in the rivers during the 19th
and early 20th centuries, before they
reached mills or sites for removal.
Lying well-preserved on the bottom,
these logs known as "deadheads" are valued
for their tight grain and colors such
as blond, caramel and black. The logs
are up to 10 times as valuable as timber
harvested from the land. Far larger than
anything available today, one old-growth
log might carry a price tag of $50,000.
Along with a $50,000 bond and a
$10,000 license, a logger might be
required to pay the state 20% of the
wood's value to compensate for the loss
of state-owned property. And such a
sweetheart deal, say critics, runs counter
to the gratuities clause of the Georgia
Constitution, which says that the state
cannot provide a private benefit at a public
cost.
Right now, though, courtesy of the
Georgia General Assembly, it appears that
deadhead logging will begin in the Flint
and Altamaha rivers in 2006.
|