By Rona Beame
December 4 2004
It is 7:30 in the morning. A terrified
7-year-old boy runs sobbing from his
house in the well to do Atlanta suburb of
Buford, Georgia. He wakes up neighbors
with nightmare words: "Daddy killed
Mommy."
Thus begins a tale of 2, perhaps 3,
murders. It is only as the police investigate
the death of the young boy's mother,
Jennifer Corbin, 33, that they uncover
links to one cold case committed 14
years before in Richmond County and
perhaps to another cold case in Alabama.
July 6 1990
The body of Dorothy "Dolly" Hearn,
27, a strikingly beautiful dental student is
discovered by her roommate on the
couch in their living room. She has a
gunshot wound to her head and there is
a 38-caliber revolver on her lap. A pot of
spaghetti sits on the stove.
Richmond County police think she is
a suicide. The sheriff's office thinks otherwise
and the case remains open but
unsolved.
Dolly's family is sure she has been
murdered. They suspect her boyfriend of
more than a year, fellow dental student
Barton Corbin, then 27. Her family hires
a forensic pathologist to oversee the
autopsy and an investigator. The pathologist,
Dr. Joe Burton, says suicide cannot
be ruled out.
A good friend of Dolly's, Travis
Hampton recalls that Dolly had become
fearful of Corbin and was trying to break
up the relationship. She was hoping "he'd
just graduate and get out of her life," says
Travis.
Shortly before the murder, strange
things happen. Her apartment and car are
vandalized, tires slashed, paint poured
into the car's gas tank and her beloved
cat disappears. A few days later, Corbin
volunteers to help her find the cat. They
drive for miles. "Amazingly" he takes her
to the exact spot and the cat is found.
Dolly reports these events to the
police but says she "doesn't want to prosecute."
Her father gives her the 38-caliber
revolver.
Eric Rader, also a student at the
Medical College of Georgia's School of
Dentistry, is a good friend of Corbin's. He
is with him when they learn of Dolly's
death. Earlier Corbin told Rader that he
knew Dolly had a gun. Now he appears
"very agitated," Rader recalls. "He asks
me not to tell the cops that he knew about
the gun."
So when the police call Rader, he
does not volunteer any information about
the gun and the police don't ask. But
Rader does tell the Hearn's private investigator,
hoping he will pass it on to the
Richmond police. Unfortunately he doesn't.
It is only recently that the Richmond
police learn from Rader that Corbin
knew about the gun.
"I felt bad I didn't tell everything I
knew the first time. I figured they'd come
back to me, but they didn't. They were
treating it as a suicide."
"You can't get it into your brain that
a friend may have killed somebody,"
Rader says. "You so much want to believe
that your friend is not a murderer."
November 2004,
Thanksgiving Day
Jennifer and Corbin, now 41, and their 2
sons Dalton, 7, and Dillon, 5, are driving
to the house of Jennifer's sister for
Thanksgiving dinner. On the way, Corbin
reveals that he knows that Jennifer is having
an Internet relationship. He is very
angry and abusive.
(For months Jennifer, a part time
preschool teacher, corresponds with a
man named Chris on the Internet and
writes him passionate letters. She confides
that her marriage is unhappy. Then
recently she learns that "Chris" is a
woman named Anita. She is stunned but
decides to maintain the friendship. She
tells her sister Heather, "Anita has shown
me I don't have to be unhappy the rest of
my life." Jennifer tells her family she is
ready to leave Corbin.)
They arrive at her sister Heather's
house and Corbin does not join in the
Thanksgiving festivities. He stays mostly
in the basement by himself, according to
Jennifer's father, Max Barber. In the car
going home Corbin continues to yell at
Jennifer and then punches her in the face
in front of the kids.
When they get home, Jennifer calls
her sister Heather. In the background
Heather can hear Corbin shouting, "I
didn't hit her. It's her word against
mine." Max Barber tells Jennifer to come
back to Heather's house with the children.
She does but only stays the night.
November 29 2004
Corbin files for divorce asking for their
home, furniture and custody of their children.
December 1 2004
At 6 in the morning Jennifer finds the
contents of her purse scattered all over
the floor. Her cell phone and credit cards
are missing. When Jennifer confronts
Corbin he refuses to give them back and
rushes out of the house in a towel. He
backs the car out of the driveway, running
over Jennifer's foot.
Jennifer calls 911. She does not
complain of any violence, so police do
not respond to the call. But she does tell
her mother that she is "deeply worried
about Corbin's violent behavior towards
her and her sons."
December 3 2004
Corbin spends the evening drinking beer
with a friend and his brother at the Wild
Wing Cafe. He is there until 1 a.m. He
charges the drinks to his credit card.
December 4 2004
At 12: 30 a.m. Jennifer talks to Anita
on the phone.
At 7:30 a.m. Dalton Corbin discovers
his mother's dead body and wakes up
their neighbors, the Comeaus. Kelly
Comeau goes next store and finds her
best friend's body. She carries 5-year-old
Dillon home with her.
The police arrive at 8 a.m. and find
an old 38-caliber Smith and Wesson lying
on the bed. They consider the death a
suicide.
December 5 2004
At a news conference, Steve Comeau
says that the night of Jennifer's death he
was up around 2 a.m. smoking a cigarette
in the garage when he saw Corbin
pull into the couple's driveway in his
Chevy pickup truck and leave 25 minutes
later. "I said to myself, I hope he didn't
do anything stupid. It just seemed odd
that he was there for such a short amount
of time," Steve says.
December 6 2004
Corbin calls his sons for the first
time since their mother's death. They are
staying with Jennifer's parents.
Jennifer's family creates a web site in
her memory. Someone identified only as
"Hearn-St. Joseph, MO" posts a condolence:
"My prayers and thoughts are with
you all. I am so sorry for any part I may
have played in this horrible tragedy."
Bizarrely, Anita has the same last
name as Dolly Hearn. But it seems to be a
coincidence. As Gwinnett County District
Attorney Danny Porter says later, "Anita is
not related in any way to Dolly's family."
December 7 2004
Jennifer's death is reclassified from
suicide to a "suspicious death."
Explaining their decision, DA Porter
says, "The bullet wound is behind, in the
rear quadrant of her head. I mean, it's
just sort of common sense-how do you
hold a gun at that angle..and pull the
trigger and have that trajectory. It leads
you very strongly to the opinion that this
was not a self-inflicted gunshot wound."
December 10 2004
Heather is granted custody of the 2
boys. Corbin doesn't show up at the hearing.
He declines a police interview and
hires attorney Doug Peters.
December 11 2004
There are hundreds of mourners at
Jennifer's funeral. Corbin and his mother
attend. Surprisingly Dolly's parents are
also there. The 2 women's families have
never met before.
Later that day Porter announces that
Corbin is a suspect in his wife's murder.
When a witness comes forward with new
information about Dolly's case, Porter
contacts Richmond County and they
reopen their investigation. Both district
attorneys are struck by the similarities
between the two murders.
. Both deaths are staged to look
like suicides.
. Both women are shot once in
the head.
. Both "suicide" guns are 38-caliber.
. Both women call the police to
report harassment by Corbin.
. Both women want to extricate
themselves from their
relationship with Corbin.
December 13 2004
Corbin says on TV, "I've been persecuted
in the media for the last ten days. I'm
anxious to speak, but have not because of
legal advice. The truth will come out in
the end."
December 22 2004
At a press conference Richmond
County District Attorney Daniel Craig says
that the grand jury has indicted Corbin on
2 counts of felony murder and 1 count of
malice murder in Hearn's death.
Barton Corbin is arrested and jailed
in Richmond County. He hires new counsel,
Bruce Harvey and David Wolfe, both
of Atlanta.
Dolly Hearn's death is no longer a
cold case.
January 4 2005
A month after the murder there's still
a sign in the window of Corbin's Dacula
dental office, "Now Accepting New Patients."
But the office is dark and someone has
scrawled on the wall in red, "Murderer."
January 5 2005
The Gwinnett County grand jury
indicts Corbin on 11 count of murder for
the death of Jennifer Corbin, 1 count of
felony murder and 1 count of possessing
a firearm in the commission of a felony.
Earlier in the day, Superior Court
Judge Debra Turner issues a gag order.
She also rejects a motion for a change of
venue from defense lawyers.
Then the Gwinnett County police get
a call from the family of a dental hygienist,
Harriet Gray, 56, who disappeared
from her home in DeKalb County in
1996. A bag of spilled groceries were
near her front door. Her body was found
a year later inside her Toyota Camry at
the bottom of a lake near Tuscaloosa,
Alabama. Her hands were duct-taped to
the steering wheel of her car. A roll of
tape was found in her lap.
Gray's son-in-law Karl Lust says, "I
can't comment on the situation, but I can
say they did know each other." Corbin
and Gray both worked for the same dentist
at different times. Gray worked for Dr.
Richard Huey in the early l980s and then
again in the mid 1990s. Corbin worked
for him in 1991.
In a phone interview, Dr. John
McDuffy chief forensic pathologist in
Tuscaloosa County says, "Her body was
badly decomposed. But there was no
other apparent cause of death, aside
from drowning."
When this reporter asks Porter if he
knows the actual cause of death in
Harriet Gray's case, he replies he can't
answer because that information may
become part of the trial.
Alabama authorities are presently
consulting with the Richmond County DA
and Sheriff's office.
January 19 2005
Corbin is moved to the jail in
Gwinnett County.
September - October
2005
Corbin's attorneys file a series of
motions that up to the writing of this article
have not been decided:
. They claim police illegally searched
the dentist's home and tapped
his cell phone.
. They ask that the indictment filed last
year be thrown out as the 14-year
interval makes it impossible for
Corbin to prepare a defense and that
authorities have lost "valuable and
potentially exculpatory evidence."
November 14 2005
Richmond County Superior Court
Judge Carl C Brown, Jr. hears a request
from the prosecution that "similar transaction"
evidence concerning Jennifer's
death be allowed at the Augusta trial.
DA Craig argues that Corbin "used
the same script" in both cases. He describes Jennifer's death: "Having shot
herself in the head and then having the
presence of mind to pull the gun away
from her head against the force of gravity,
then placing it on the bed, then pulling
the bed covers over it. I think we'll show
scientifically that this case is a murder
and that the 2 deaths are linked."
Craig points out that both women
were killed after trying to break off a relationship
with Corbin. "The motive is
clear," says Craig. "You don't break up with
Corbin. If you do, you pay with your life."
Defense council Bruce Harvey contends
both women committed suicide
and it would be "highly prejudicial" if
evidence from the Gwinnett death was
included at the Augusta trial.
At the hearing Harvey reads more
than a dozen e-mails Jennifer sent to
Anita. Some of the e-mails are sexually
explicit. One describes a violent fantasy
including a loaded revolver.
In another e-mail Jennifer says, "I
just can't take this. I even fell in love with
the name Chris. I trusted you. I can't
believe you did this to me." Harvey says
Jennifer committed suicide because she
was distraught over her marriage falling
apart and she feared losing her 2 children
when it came out that her Internet
lover was a female.
Craig says that for years Corbin has
been having an affair with another
woman. He also says there was new evidence
for both trials-witnesses who
can place Corbin at Hearn's apartment
the day her body was found and cell
phone records that show Corbin was
near his home when his wife died.
Corbin's brother maintains that
Barton was at his home in Auburn the
night Jennifer died.
Judge Brown does not make a decision
on the "similar transaction" motion
and sets a date for another hearing.
April 17 2006
Jennifer trial is scheduled to begin April
17. Perhaps then we'll learn the answers
to some puzzling questions.
. Why did son Dalton say his
father killed his mother?
. Who is Corbin having an affair with?
. Was there gunshot residue
on Corbin's hands?
. What happened to Jennifer's
hard drive?
. How did Corbin find out
about Jennifer's Internet friend?
. What caused Harriet Gray's death?
And of course, most important, is
Barton Corbin innocent or is he a serial
killer?
|